The Tasks AI Should Handle—and Those It Shouldn't
Follow us
Understanding AI's Role in the Workplace
Generative AI is making waves in the world of work, offering a glimpse into how it might redefine various jobs. But as we delve into this technology, it's crucial to shift our focus from what AI can do to what it should do. This subtle but important distinction helps us understand the broader implications of AI in the workplace.
Can AI Take Over Every Job?
When we talk about AI's impact on jobs, the conversation often revolves around whether AI can perform specific tasks. For example, in a call center, a customer service representative typically handles tasks like speaking with customers, logging their concerns, and resolving or escalating issues. Generative AI can manage these tasks, suggesting that such roles might be at risk of automation.
However, let's consider a similar role: an emergency service phone operator. While these jobs share tasks like handling calls and resolving issues, the risk of automation isn't the same. It's not just about what AI can technically do; it's about weighing economic, ethical, and operational factors.
Key Questions for AI in the Workplace
Laurence Ales and Christophe Combemale, experts from Carnegie Mellon University, propose four essential questions for organizations thinking about automation:
How Complex Is the Task? Complexity often dictates whether a task can be automated. Emergency dispatchers deal with complex, varied problems that AI might struggle with, whereas repetitive customer service tasks are more suited to automation.
How Frequent Is the Task? Tasks that occur often are prime candidates for automation. Machines excel at maintaining speed and consistency over long periods, making them ideal for frequent, repetitive tasks.
How Interconnected Are the Tasks? Jobs often involve a series of interconnected tasks. When tasks are divided among different workers or machines, inefficiencies can arise. For example, if AI handles the initial customer interaction, but a human resolves the issue, important details might be lost in the transition.
What Is the Cost of Failure? Some roles, like emergency dispatchers, have high stakes where mistakes can be life-threatening. In such cases, the cost of failure is too high to risk full automation.
AI's Impact on Different Occupations
These questions help explain why AI affects some jobs more than others. Take computer programmers, for instance. Generative AI can tackle many coding tasks because of their high frequency and the availability of extensive coding examples. Innovations like modular design have also minimized fragmentation costs, making programming a field ripe for AI disruption.
The Future of Work with AI
Generative AI is a powerful tool with the potential to reshape various industries. Its ability to handle complex tasks quickly and efficiently sets it apart from traditional automation. However, the unpredictability of AI outputs can also increase the risk of errors. As AI continues to evolve, its impact on the labor market will hinge on how tasks are structured within different occupations.
In summary, while AI holds tremendous promise, its adoption will depend on a careful analysis of the complexity, frequency, interconnectedness, and risk associated with tasks in specific roles. Understanding these factors will help organizations make informed decisions about integrating AI into their operations.
